5 August 2025 The Future is the Product of the Past

New Study Disproves Roman Massacre at Maiden Castle, Revealing Complex Iron Age Conflicts

Bournemouth University Archaeologists Challenge 90-Year-Old Roman Conquest Narrative at Maiden Castle with Fresh Forensic and Radiocarbon Analysis

A landmark study by Bournemouth University (BU) archaeologists has upended a widely accepted version of ancient British history, revealing that the infamous “Roman massacre” at Maiden Castle never happened. Instead, researchers discovered that the individuals buried at the Iron Age hillfort in Dorset died during multiple episodes of localized violence spanning several generations—long before any Roman legions set foot on the site.

The study, recently published in the Oxford Journal of Archaeology, reexamines one of Britain’s most iconic archaeological discoveries using modern forensic techniques and a comprehensive radiocarbon dating program. Human remains previously interpreted as victims of a single dramatic Roman attack were actually deposited over a timeline stretching from the late 1st century BC into the early 1st century AD.

Dr. Martin Smith, Associate Professor in Forensic and Biological Anthropology at BU, explained:

“The find of dozens of human skeletons displaying lethal weapon injuries was never in doubt. However, our systematic radiocarbon analysis shows these deaths occurred across decades, rather than a single event.”

Two skeletons excavated by Mortimer Wheeler in the 1930s, dating back to the 1st century AD, both show injuries caused by bladed weapons. One of these individuals even has a spearhead embedded in his spine, which was previously (and incorrectly) identified as a Roman ballista bolt. Credit: Martin Smith
Two skeletons excavated by Mortimer Wheeler in the 1930s, dating back to the 1st century AD, both show injuries caused by bladed weapons. One of these individuals even has a spearhead embedded in his spine, which was previously (and incorrectly) identified as a Roman ballista bolt. Credit: Martin Smith

Originally excavated in 1936 by famed archaeologist Sir Mortimer Wheeler, Maiden Castle became a cultural symbol of resistance, allegedly representing the violent clash between the native Durotriges tribe and invading Roman forces. Wheeler’s vivid account of a Roman siege, complete with “marks of battle” and a tale of noble but futile resistance, helped etch the site into the national narrative as the setting of a tragic massacre.

But modern science tells a different story.

Dr. Miles Russell, Principal Academic in Prehistoric and Roman Archaeology at BU and co-author of the study, remarked:

“Since the 1930s, this story of a doomed native last stand has permeated books, articles, and documentaries. But our findings show it simply doesn’t hold up under scrutiny. The injuries are real, but the pattern, spread over decades, points not to Roman soldiers—but to inter-tribal violence or ritual killings by fellow Britons.”

Injuries observed on the skeletons include blunt force trauma and sharp-force lesions, but lack the consistency and concentration expected from organized Roman military tactics. Moreover, variations in burial practices suggest complex social dynamics at play. According to Visiting Fellow and archaeological scientist Paul Cheetham,

“The burial diversity suggests either co-existing cultures or intricate social stratification within Iron Age society. It’s no longer valid to impose simplistic interpretations on such complex archaeological contexts.”

The research also raises compelling questions about what remains hidden beneath the site. Wheeler’s initial excavation, though groundbreaking for its time, only covered a fraction of the expansive hillfort. Cheetham added,

“It’s likely that many more burials remain undiscovered around the vast ramparts of Maiden Castle.”

A skeleton with a spearhead lodged in the spine, previously (and mistakenly) identified as a bolt or arrowhead from a Roman ballista. Credit: Martin Smith
A skeleton with a spearhead lodged in the spine, previously (and mistakenly) identified as a bolt or arrowhead from a Roman ballista. Credit: Martin Smith

Dr. Smith noted how contemporary influences may have shaped earlier interpretations:

“Wheeler was working on the eve of WWII, with Britain fearing another foreign invasion. That kind of anxiety might have made the idea of a heroic stand against the Romans resonate more deeply.”

This new study calls for a reevaluation not only of Maiden Castle but of how historical narratives are constructed—and how they persist, even in the face of contradictory evidence.

By employing modern archaeological science, Bournemouth University researchers have not only dismantled a myth but replaced it with a richer, more human story—one that acknowledges the complexities of Iron Age life, social conflict, and the long shadow of impending conquest.

Smith, M. J., Russell, M., & Cheetham, P. (2025). Fraught with high tragedy: A contextual and chronological reconsideration of the Maiden Castle Iron Age ‘war cemetery’ (England). Oxford Journal of Archaeology, 44(2), 123–140. https://doi.org/10.1111/ojoa.12324

Bournemouth University

Cover Image Credit: Aerial view of Maiden Castle, Dorset, the largest Iron Age hillfort in Britain. Credit: Jo and Sue Crane

Related Articles

2400-year-old artifacts discovered in the Black Sea’s first scientific underwater excavation

25 March 2024

25 March 2024

Dozens of historical artifacts dating from the 4th century BC to the 12th century AD were unearthed in the first...

Artificial Intelligence Project That Will Revolutionize Archaeology

5 April 2021

5 April 2021

Polish Scientists to opening a new era in archeology They plan to use artificial intelligence to detect prehistoric cemeteries, castles,...

Anthropologists say humans have been using personal ornaments to communicate about themselves without the fuss of conversation – for millennia

24 September 2021

24 September 2021

Anthropologists believe that for millennia, individuals have used personal decorations to communicate about themselves without the hassle of dialogue. They...

Artificial intelligence is Detecting New Archaeological Sites in the Arabian desert

5 October 2024

5 October 2024

A team of researchers at Khalifa University in Abu Dhabi has developed a machine-learning algorithm to help them trawl vast...

Medallion of Emperor Caracalla Minted in Pergamon Found in Roman Tombs in Bulgaria

13 February 2024

13 February 2024

One of the valuable discoveries from the Roman tombs discovered near the village of Nova Varbovka in Strazhitsa municipality in...

Tajik Buddha in Nirvana – the Largest in the World: 42 feet long and 9 feet high

31 December 2023

31 December 2023

In the past, while Taliban soldiers in Afghanistan destroyed two immense statues of Buddha, art historians in neighboring Tajikistan meticulously...

Ancient Hittite Bronze Helmet Unearthed: A Rare Glimpse into the Warrior Culture of a Forgotten Empire

5 June 2025

5 June 2025

3,300-Year-Old War Helmet Reveals the Power, Beliefs, and Craftsmanship of the Hittite Civilization A rare 3,300-year-old bronze helmet discovered in...

4,400 Years Old Shaman Snake Staff Found in Finland

29 June 2021

29 June 2021

A very well-preserved 4,400-year-old Shaman Snake Staff made of wood has been found in Finland. The “Snake Staff” found is...

The marble head of God Apollo unearthed in an excavation at Philippi, Greece

29 March 2024

29 March 2024

The excavation, carried out by a group of students of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki in the archaeological site of...

Underwater Archaeologists Discover a 7,000-Year-Old Road in Croatia

8 May 2023

8 May 2023

A team of underwater archaeologists from the University of Zadar has discovered the sunken ruins of a 7,000-year-old road that...

A newly Discovered Church in Sudan could be a Cathedral

2 June 2021

2 June 2021

Archaeologists have found the remains of the largest church known from medieval Nubia in old Dongola (Sudan). Dongola was the...

From Bronze Age to Buddhism: Xinjiang’s Archaeological Journey Through Time and Recent Discoveries

4 March 2025

4 March 2025

Recent archaeological investigations in the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region have significantly enhanced our understanding of the area’s historical context and...

Albastı “A Mother’s Nightmare “

5 February 2021

5 February 2021

Albastı is one of the bad characters in Turkish mythology. The fearful dream of puerperal women and babies, Albastı continues...

An Unusual Artifact Points to Roman Britain Rituals Linked to Fertility, Painted Dog Penis Bone Found in England

9 January 2025

9 January 2025

In a Roman quarry shaft in Surrey, England, archaeologists have discovered one of the most unusual human and animal remains...

5,000-Year-Old Burial of High-Status Woman with Feathered Mantle Unearthed in Ancient Caral

27 April 2025

27 April 2025

Archaeologists in Peru have announced the remarkable discovery of a 5,000-year-old burial of a woman of high social standing at...